Posted by: morethananelectrician | July 5, 2008

Tears from a five year old

Game two is in the books.    The team we played this week was much better than last week, but we still managed a victory with almost all egos intact.

I avoided an issue with a father, but ended up causing and issue with the child.  It is always so hard to keep everyone happy.

The age ranges in on my team are from 5-8 years old and there is a big difference is ability from 5 to 8.    Especially since these 8 year olds played with me last year and the 5 year olds are just playing for the first time.  These 5 years olds have to handles cautiously.   If I put them in a position they are uncomfortable with and they fail, the ramifications can be detrimental to the child, parent and, therefore, the coach too.

The way I am handling my two five year olds this season is to play them at linebacker on defense during the game.   At this position, they have one job and only one job…GO GET THE FLAG!    They don’t have to concern themselves with containment on the outside or letting anyone get by them.   The ball is snapped and they can go in “flag” mode.   I practice them in other positions, but I limit their decision making responsibilities until they are more familiar to the game.    

This is really puts them in only a position to succeed.   If they miss someone, there are people all around them.   As they advance in confidence, I can move them to other positions.

On offense, I will play them at receiver on plays that we are running the ball.    Most five year olds, when chased, will just turn and run in the other direction.   As cute as this is and as much as the parents laugh, the parent of the child running in the wrong direction is embarrassed and nothing good happens.   I can teach the five year old in practice and tell him before the play, but no matter what, they just turn and run the wrong way and they end up feeling bad for failing no matter how I try to fix it.

The theory is that I can teach them the basic skill set at five and advance them to more skilled positions as they advance in age and skills.   Not only do we have a football game to play, but I need to make sure that each of the kids (and the parents) leave the field with a smile on their face…if possible.

This makes the practices much more enjoyable than the games. 

At the practices, I get to teach, play and build up the confidence of the boys and girls. 

At the practices, I can spend one on one time with the kids.

At the game, I am just trying to make sure everyone plays about the same amount of time, doesn’t get hurt and hopefully leaves the field with smiles.

This dad insisted that he had been working with his 5 year old and that he wanted to be a running back.  We were about five minutes from the end of the game when he brought this to my attention.  

I gave him my “fragile confidence level of the kids” speech that I have perfected and what my plan was for the whole season.   This was only week two and we had many other games to build his confidence up to put him in at running back.  He insisted that his boy would run in the right direction (because he had older brothers) and he knew his son could handle this.

This cordial conversation went on for about a minute and it ended with me doing something that I usually don’t do…

I went against the plan that I use, and have used since I started coaching when i was 15, to help these kids gain confidence, learn skills and have fun all at the same time.

Just because I have been doing things with positive results for years on end, doesn’t mean that there isn’t a better way of accomplishing the same goals.

Sometimes, when you try a new process, things turn out even better than they were before…

This was not one of those times!

The boy froze, the quarterback ran to him and gave him the ball and the boy took two steps forward and darted in the other direction into the opposite end zone.  All of the parents we enjoying the “cuteness” of the events that unfolded in front of us except for me and the parent of the boy who had run in the wrong direction.

I had seen this before and ran out to the field to keep this 5 year old’s spirits up and get to him before he came to the sidelines.  By the time the I made it to him, he was already in tears. 

While trying to keep everyone happy, I allowed this little boy to be put in a position for this to happen.  

The father didn’t scold the boy or treat him poorly.   I really think that he was trying to give his boy some confidence, but was a bit blinded by it being his son.  My job was to put everything in perspective and do the right thing for the boy and not the father.

I failed to do so and this boy took quite a blow today that could have, and most certainly should have,  been avoided.

This wasn’t a case of a dad putting too much pressure on me.  This was a case of me being blinded by a father wanting to build up his son.  I understood him and when I looked into the 5 year old’s eyes before the play, he looked like he was ready.

I can fix this, it is just going to take a couple of weeks.   Many of you who are not fans of team sports will use this as an example of why they are bad.  But this is just a mistake by a coach, not an example of too much pressure and influence from a parent.    I have a very good plan for these kids and have been teaching boys and girls the skills necessary to gain the confidence and skills to enjoy these game, be good teammates and have good sportsmanship in the process.

I “dropped the ball” today.


Responses

  1. It was unfortunate, but an experience that all three of you can learn from. You are a great coach. You have all season to build him back up and you will do it. My guess is also that the kid’s Dad will let you be the coach and make the calls going forward (which is a good thing).

    Overall, I agree with your coaching style and skill building stategy. Things will go wrong from time to time. That is one of the biggest lessons that the kids learn. In life you do not always win and, yes, you make mistakes. The good news is that every game gives you the opportunity for a “do over” so that you again can try your hardest. It is these life lessons that makes team sports so valuable. The lessons that the kids are learning are just as valuable as math, english and science.

    The rest of the team handled “the wrong way” issue very well, with my son being the worst. He grabbed his own flag and threw it on the ground. I needed to make sure his team mates weren’t too harsh. It ended up alright.

  2. I hope the kid’s father apologized to you & admitted the whole thing was his fault. Yes, I realize you’re the coach, but you clearly warned him & he continued to push it. I think your empathy for the child is really sweet & I’m sure he’ll walk away happy to have had you as a coach. Experiencing even one good, caring coach in a lifetime is a wonderful thing. So many suck!

    I think is one of the times apologies weren’t required. I am a bit of a “hot head” by nature and it takes every fiber of my being to mask it. I didn’t need an issue here. I have actually coached one of his other boys in another sport and being borderline OCD, I coach each sport the same. It isn’t very hard to remember how my boy was at five (which is exactly how I was too), and I really try to think of each one as my own kid when something like this happens. It just burns me up when I think of that boy going to sleep tonight and thinking about that play today.

  3. It’s great that you will take all the blame for this but the dad should have let the coach do the coaching and not tried to convince you. He shares equally in the blame for any lasting issues that this kid would suffer. I don’t have much experience with 5 year olds, but wont this all be a distant memory soon enough anyway?

    Oh…James. I remember events from when I was five. We never know the events that shape and mold us until they have already passed. I am here to make sure those are memories are positive and not negative. Combined in the four sports I coach, I see between 40-50 kids a year (some of them are repeats from one sport to another).

    The issue is that blame is an “after the fact” judgement. These things need to be handled before they get to that point. Which…is my responsibility.

  4. Five years old is really young to be trying to grasp all the ins and outs of football. As a parent, I understand the dad being overly confident in his kid. I think we all do that from time to time. Being the coach seems like a major juggling act and I give you credit for trying to keep everything in balance. If anyone can restore that boy’s confidence, I think it’s you.

    I try not to put too much pressure on the youngest kids in which ever age group, or sport, I am coaching. Football is a real challenge…I created a position for them. I call them “Flag Hounds”. They have no responsibilities other than grabbing flags.

    In baseball, my young ones don’t pitch much. Walking batters can be tough on a kid standing in the middle of the field by himself. We play some intra-squad scrimmages where I let them get their innings.

    In basketball, no point guard play. But soccer is the easiest, because I can teach any kid how to play defense.

    I will fix this.

  5. I’m sure the dad probably worked with the kid one-on-one and thought he knew what to do, but he forgot that one-on-one coaching is not the same as being surrounded by a whirlwind of a dozen other kids.

    Maybe now that he’s made a mistake and will remember it, maybe giving him the ball again would result in him running in the right direction and getting a confidence boost?

    I dunno, I have basically no coaching experience and you do. I can definitely empathize with both you and the kid, though. Hopefully he can bounce back with a grin.

  6. I think the kid will be alright. The parent, however, may have more trouble getting over his embarrassment.

    I’m with Taoist Biker—-give the kid the ball again. I think he will run in the right direction this time and what a confidence booster that will be. To know that in spite of his last mistake, you still believe in him. I bet he’ll grin from ear to ear.

  7. We’ll wait a couple of weeks before putting him in that position again. I have a couple of drills where I put someone chasing them from behind BEFORE they ever get the ball that should help him out before throwing him into the fire again.

  8. Sounds to me like you have got a great approach to the game. Everyone makes mistakes occasionally. Treat this as one to learn from. If anything, it hopefully proved to the Dad to not interfere.

    Keep up the good work

  9. I just started my 5.5 year old in flag football and it has been a long month first month. We’re practicing MF 6p-8p until school starts and have scrimmages on Sat’s until the season begins. The age group is 5-7 year olds, most players are 6-7, so it’s been tough on my 5 year old trying to keep up. That being said, he is hanging in there. He’s playing running back and linebacker, learning his gaps….all the basics, which is great. But he does tend to run the wrong way when running the ball (we play all 11 positions and there’s quite a bit of contact and blocking) or straight to the sidelines due to the size and speed of his teammates. At first I thought it was because he was not paying attention and didn’t understand to run forward, but I quickly realized that he’s somewhat afraid….which is normal. He’s the only 5 year old playing running back (coaches decision, not mine), so he’s stands out a little when he’s timid. But once again, he’s hanging in there and seems to love to play. I’m glad you shared the fact that you like to play the younger kids at linebacker – my son absolutley loves playing linebacker…makes sense as to why, simply get the flags and you did your job.

    One concern I have is the lack of attention/effort he gives the coaches at practice. He seems to drift off during drills and runs to the wrong gaps at times, even though he know’s them like his abc’s. When I practice with him on the weekends, he runs twice as fast, knows every hole and catches the ball really well. When he practices with his team, he runs half speed and misses half of his plays. It’s like he’s a completely different kid. I know he’s only 5 and their attention span is very short, but I’m a little concerned that he might be bored and maybe not fully into playing. I played my whole life and he knows all about it. I’m afraid he’s playing because he likes the idea of being a football player, however, playing mainly because he wants to be like his Dad and/or doesn’t want to let me down. In no way am I pushing him, I just don’t know if playing him at 5 was the right decision. Probably over thinking this whole thing…..but any advice on how I can convince him to play full speed with his team and pay attention would help. Also, should he be playing running back at all – is he too young?

    Thank you

  10. Don’t panic, he is just a five year old and focus is the one thing that they are not the best at…

    For the young one’s I like to have them pretend that someone is chasing them from behind to get them moving. When we run drills in practice, I will actually get behind them and chase them, pulling on their shirt while they wer running. It allows them to focus on going straight upfield and not trying to run around everyone.

    If he is enjoying it, then he is doing just fine. He will let you know if he doesn’t like playing. Give him this year to learn and get a feel for being on the field with so many kids…that is a lot to grasp and he will “loosen” up next season.

    Just encourage him.

  11. That’s what I needed to hear. Thanks for the advice and best of luck this season.


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories